"Very creative approach to linking microbiomes and learning! It could benefit from showing how success would be measured in simple, concrete terms like: time saved in training animals"

"The idea is bold and innovative - you might strengthen it by addressing ethical concerns early on, since transferring memories biologically raises sensitive questions."

"Great concept! It would be even stronger if you clarified what kind of skills or behaviors could realistically be transferred first, as a proof of concept."

"Interesting idea, but I wonder if it might be jumping a few steps ahead. We still don’t fully understand how memory is encoded in the brain itself — so building a system to move that across species through microbes feels like a massive leap. Maybe…"

"This is such a wild concept — transferring learning biologically almost sounds like science fiction. I’m curious how you’d even begin to prove that a behavior was “transferred” rather than just influenced. The line between correlation and true…"

"The idea is highly creative and thought-provoking. To make it stronger, you could connect it more closely to existing research and explain more clearly how the biological transfer of learning might be achieved in practice"

"You’ve presented a highly original perspective on learning and biological information transfer. It could be improved by clarifying what “learning signature” means experimentally and suggesting how success might be measured or validated in a real…"

"This concept is incredibly bold and imaginative — merging microbiome science with memory transfer is a fascinating direction. To strengthen it, consider addressing the ethical and biological feasibility aspects more clearly, as that would ground the…"

"It’s a fascinating idea — almost sci-fi in its ambition. But I keep wondering where the line would be between “transferring” memory and unintentionally altering behavior. Maybe exploring the ethical and regulatory side could add a lot of depth to…"

"Really interesting idea — transferring learned behavior biologically is a wild concept. That said, it feels like the science behind how memories are stored and shared is still a huge gap. I’d be curious to see how you’d test this in a realistic…"

"A bold and imaginative idea, but translating learned behaviors through microbiomes faces major scientific and ethical barriers. The concept is fascinating, yet its practical viability remains highly uncertain."

"An intriguing concept, but memory is complex and not easily reduced to microbial signals. Safety, ethics, and feasibility remain major hurdles before such an idea could move beyond theory."

"Extremely interesting idea! Presenting the microbiome as a possible vessel for transmitted learning behavior brings a completely new perspective to the gut–brain connection. Utilizing genetically engineered bacteria as biological recorders for…"

"This is a really thought-provoking and groundbreaking idea! You’ve connected microbiome science, synthetic biology, and neuroscience in a way that feels both futuristic and practical. The concept of “biological skill transfer” could redefine how we…"

"This is a much-needed idea — the way you’re categorizing notifications into Urgent, Useful, and Promotional feels intuitive and could genuinely reduce digital clutter. I especially like that it’s privacy-friendly and learns on-device instead of…"