"idea seems mediocre cause it doesnt seem realistic. try better good luck!"

"It's basics and offers a user-friendly experience, but there’s room to expand its features for those looking for a more comprehensive tracking tool"

"For a busy person the app sounds great. With that said, the app might benefit from adding a bit more functionality over time—such as reminders, barcode scanning, or integration with fitness trackers—to enhance user engagement and accuracy"

"A developers assistance is definitely required for backend, However I would definitely be mainly doing the ui"

"Yeah i think a good notification system may just improve this issue!"

"Oh thats a great suggestion! I would definetly consider it"

"I like the idea of easy diet tracking! Would you consider adding workouts or recipe ideas to your app?"

"GymRat has a good foundation and a clear purpose, but it might come across as too simple. The minimal design is appealing, yet adding one or two unique touches—like gentle reminders or progress insights—could make it feel more purposeful and stand…"

"GymRat would be a clean and easy-to-use app for tracking protein and calories, but its simplicity might leave detailed trackers wanting more."

"Will this app be able to track the small details that usually go unnoticed when tracking calories? I feel like that would be a good differentiating factor from the existing alternatives to your app."

"This would be a huge hit in the gym world, i could see this project coming to reality! keep at it the market is there!"

"It’s a nice idea, but it feels too basic—like something you could just do in Notes. The “simplicity” sounds more like a lack of features than a design choice. It needs a clearer reason to exist."

"As a good future business, how would you exapnd. And would you be making the ui all by yourself, or would you take external help?"

"Design and pitch seems good. However gymrat seems like a very common idea. could be a bit more unique?"

"Nice that GymRat positions itself differently from detailed trackers. Simplicity as an advantage is a smart angle."

"I really like the concept behind GymRat! The simplicity is definitely the strongest point — most nutrition apps overwhelm users with too many stats and features, so having a clean, minimal diary-style tracker is refreshing. The focus on protein…"