"The proposal asserts impact but lacks quantitative data. What is the estimated cost per installation (both ambulance and signal)? What is the projected, measurable reduction in response time in a dense urban setting (not a highway)? Without a…"

"The transmitter-receiver model is a proven but potentially outdated approach. Why not leverage more modern, dynamic technologies? A GPS-based system integrated with Google Maps or a dedicated 5G network could predict an ambulance's route and…"

"The system's effectiveness depends on the near-perfect functioning of every transmitter and receiver. Given the harsh environmental conditions in many Indian cities (dust, extreme heat, monsoon rains), what is the projected failure rate? Who is…"

"What happens when two ambulances equipped with SmartCorridor approach the same intersection from different directions? The current proposal lacks a clear protocol for resolving such conflicts. Who gets priority? This could lead to a dangerous…"

"Integration with city traffic control centers is easier said than done. It involves navigating complex and often siloed municipal departments, each with its own legacy systems and political priorities. A pilot on a single highway (NH66) is a…"

"The document claims the system is "customized for Indian conditions" but offers no specifics. Indian traffic is uniquely chaotic, involving jaywalkers, stray animals, roadside vendors, and a general lack of lane discipline. A green light does not…"

"While "encrypted transmitter IDs" are mentioned, this is a superficial nod to a deep security problem. What specific encryption standard will be used? How will the system prevent replay attacks or signal spoofing? A malicious actor could clone a…"

"Forcing a "green corridor" on one route inevitably means creating a "red wall" on all intersecting routes. In dense, gridlocked Indian cities, holding traffic for even an extra 60-90 seconds can trigger a cascading gridlock that takes hours to…"

"The proposal's claim of being "cost-effective" hinges on using existing Vehicle Actuated Control (VAC) signals. This assumes that a significant number of signals are not only VAC-enabled but also properly maintained and integrated. What percentage…"

"This is a creative and impactful idea with a clear problem and innovative solution—turning everyday vehicles into passive street cleaners is compelling. The strengths are its scalability, citizen-driven model, and clear benefits for governments,…"

"This is a strong pitch with a clear structure and good use of the UPI analogy. 👍 You’ve defined the problem well and shown both customer and provider benefits.

That said, it’s a bit wordy—bullet points could make it sharper. The market gaps can…"

"This is a fantastic idea! The concept of SmartCorridor addresses a critical issue in urban India-ambulances getting stuck in traffic, which can delay life-saving treatment. By leveraging existing VAC-enabled traffic signals, it provides a…"

"Your idea smartly tackles a critical issue with a cost-effective, scalable approach using existing VAC signals. Encryption and city-wide integration add strong foresight. The key challenge will be coordinating across municipal systems and…"

"This is a really smart idea! One thing to consider is ensuring the system handles multiple ambulances or emergency vehicles simultaneously without causing traffic confusion."

"Great initiative 👏! Eco Lids tackle a silent but massive plastic problem in a practical way by turning farm waste into value. Love how it balances affordability with sustainability — exactly what’s needed for real adoption in India. Excited to see…"