Share your Ideas here. Be as descriptive as possible. Ask for feedback. If you find any interesting Idea, you can comment and encourage the person in taking it forward.
Key gaps in current solutions / market
Very low recovery rates from post-consumer streams. Estimates put recycled rare-earth recovery at under ~1% of demand today — the “urban mine” is barely tapped.
Collection is generalized, not magnet-aware. Existing e-waste collection services largely treat electronics in bulk; they don’t capture the small, dispersed magnet payloads (hard drives, motors, speakers) and so valuable magnets get shredded, melted or lost to slag.
Low consumer awareness + weak incentives. Consumers and small businesses don’t know magnets are valuable, and current paybacks for small-volume drop-offs rarely justify the effort of separate disassembly.
High manual disassembly cost & safety issues. Recovering magnets often requires opening devices and carefully removing coated/cemented parts; manual labor and safety (strong magnets, sharp parts) raise cost.
Heterogeneous feedstock / inconsistent quality. Magnets vary in alloy composition, coatings and bonding, which complicates standardization and downstream processing — buyers prefer consistent lots.
Fragmented supply chain & limited domestic processing capacity. Although new recyclers exist, domestic capacity is nascent relative to projected demand — logistics and scale matter.
No widely accepted provenance/traceability model. Buyers (industrial/defense/auto) will pay more for traceable, certified recycled feedstock; current collection lacks chain-of-custody standards.
Who benefits (and how)
End users / collectors (consumers, repair shops, small businesses)
Get cash/credits for discarded devices, or convenient scheduled pickup/dropoff with education/guides for safe extraction.
Reduced liability and simplified compliance for businesses disposing of e-waste.
Buyers / recyclers / manufacturers
Access to cleaner, pre-sorted, higher-value feedstock (magnets sorted by size/type/grade) reduces downstream processing cost.
Better forecastable feed enables recycled-content sourcing for EV motors, electronics, wind turbines.
Community & environment
Reduced environmental impact vs. mining (GHG, water, land use); less toxic waste in landfills.
Local job creation (collection hubs, certified disassembly centers) and circular-economy benefits.
Policy makers / national security
Strengthens domestic critical-materials resilience and reduces geopolitical supply risk for rare earths. Financial Times+1
Why this problem matters (plainly)
I don’t have personal feelings, but this problem is strategically important for multiple reasons: rare-earth magnets are critical to clean-energy and high-tech industries; supply is geopolitically concentrated; recycling can cut emissions and supply risk; and yet current recovery is tiny compared with future demand. Fixing the collection/logistics/incentives layer unlocks the entire recycling value chain and makes recycled supply commercially viable. Reuters+1
Short list of app features / technical details (MVP → scale)
MVP
Easy onboarding + geolocated pickup/drop points for consumers.
Device scanning (barcode/serial or photo) + heuristic to estimate magnet value (device type: HDD, motor, speaker, actuator).
Step-by-step guided disassembly (text + images + safety warnings) and short video walkthroughs for common items.
Dynamic pricing engine (per-item offers) linked to real-time buyer bids and magnet grade heuristics.
Courier integration for last-mile pickup (route optimization).
Simple KYC + small payment / wallet.
Scale / advanced
Sensor-assisted sorting partners: integrate with collection hubs that use magnetometers / nondestructive sorting to verify presence/size without full disassembly.
Quality tagging & batch creation: allow collectors to submit photos + short video; use computer vision to pre-classify magnet type and send to appropriate recycler.
API/marketplace for recyclers: receive lots, bid on them, schedule pickups.
Traceability / certification layer: issue digital certificates (optionally blockchain) with mass, composition estimates, and origin to increase buyer trust.
Incentive models: hybrid of small per-item payouts + loyalty/green credits (partner retailers or manufacturers accept credits).
Safety & compliance module: local rules per region for hazardous components; recommended partnerships with certified disassembly centers.
Comments
only thing i wonder is how easy it'll be to get regular users to do safe disassembly, even with guides. maybe more focus on partnerships with repair shops or e-waste centers who already do this work could help scale faster. either way, definitely a problem worth solving.
Strategic thinking of implementing it by offering rewards to the collector and other ways. A feasible way of implementing the app. This idea has great scope in the future if it is brought to the mainstream.
-
1
-
2
of 2 Next